Skip to main content

Gaza needs more than condemnation


Protesters demonstrate against Israel’s attacks on Gaza at the Hague on 12 July.

(Robert Soeterik)

Gaza needs more than condemnation

The Palestinians of Gaza, naively, went to the polling station in
January 2006, mistakenly believing the Bush doctrine of bringing
democracy to the Middle East — in spite of him being responsible for the
brutal massacre of hundreds of thousands of innocent people in Iraq and

People voted, but not for the preferred choice of the Israelis, or
their American backers and the Arab dictators. The Palestinian choice
was against the peace process industry, against the fiction that is the ever-slippery two-state solution, against the corruption of the Oslo-era nouveau riche.

The outcome was a surprise not only for the Oslo camp, but also for the winners themselves: Hamas. And Palestinians, especially those in Gaza, were made to pay a heavy price for this transgression: the imposition of a severe siege described by Israeli historian Ilan Pappe in 2006 as “genocide.”

But the deadly siege was not enough to satisfy Israel’s hunger for
Palestinian blood. The Palestinians of Gaza refused to passively accept
Israel’s siege, like good natives are supposed to. Hence, Israel
ferociously attacked Gaza in three horrific assaults in 2006, 2009 and
2012 and now again in 2014.

In all of these attacks, the people of Gaza were left alone to face
one of the strongest armies in the world — an army that has hundreds of
nuclear warheads, thousands of trigger-happy soldiers armed with Merkava
tanks, F-16s, Apache helicopters, naval gunships and phosphorous bombs
made in the United States. Gaza has no army, no navy and no air force.
And yet Israelis claim to be under threat and fear for their lives!


Commenting on this situation in Gaza, Karen Koning AbuZayd, former commissioner-general for UNRWA, the UN agency for Palestine refugees, said in 2008:
“Gaza is on the threshold of becoming the first territory to be
intentionally reduced to a state of abject destitution with the
knowledge, acquiescence and — some would say — encouragement of the
international community.”

We in Gaza know very well that Israel could not have carried out its
current genocidal war, preceded by this horrific siege and a series of
massacres before it, without a green light from the so-called
international community.

Tellingly, an Israeli soldier was quoted by Israel’s Haaretz
newspaper in 2009: “That’s what is so nice, supposedly, about Gaza: You
see a person on a road, walking along a path. He doesn’t have to be
with a weapon, you don’t have to identify him with anything and you can
just shoot him.”

But this aggression is not new; none of these wars have been a response to Qassam rockets fired from Gaza.

The 1948 Genocide Convention clearly states that one instance of
genocide is “the deliberate infliction of conditions of life calculated
to bring about the physical destruction of a people in whole or in

Sara Roy, an expert on Gaza, describes the Strip as follows:

[Gaza is] a land ripped apart and scarred, the lives of its
people blighted. Gaza is decaying under the weight of continued
devastation, unable to function normally …
The decline and disablement of Gaza’s economy and society have been
deliberate, the result of state policy — consciously planned,
implemented and enforced. Although Israel bears the greatest
responsibility, the United States and the European Union, among others,
are also culpable … All are complicit in the ruination of this gentle
place. And just as Gaza’s demise has been consciously orchestrated, so
have the obstacles preventing its recovery.

The Food and Agriculture Organization and World Food Program stated in a 2009 report: “The evidence shows that the population is being sustained at the most basic or minimum humanitarian standard.”

As Ilan Pappe argues in Out of the Frame,
mainstream discourse in Israel is about the need to destroy Gaza once
and for all: “today from the left to the right, from academia to the
media, one can hear the righteous anger of a state that more than any
other in the world is destroying and dispossessing an indigenous

And now, judging by the increasing air raids, the incitement
of Israel’s war-mongering generals and politicians, Israel is putting
that ideology into practice. As Thursday evening, Gaza time, the latest
statistics are horrific: 237 dead, more than 50 of them children, and
1,770 injured, according to the Gaza health ministry, and more than 1,600 homes demolished in broad daylight.

And yet those in places of power, unsurprisingly, still back Israel’s
“right to defend itself,” conveniently forgetting or in the case of the
Obama administration, denying
that those who are oppressed and dispossessed also have the right to
resist their oppression. Israel is intent on destroying Gaza and
international official bodies and administrations like Obama’s repeatedly declare their commitment to Israel’s “security” like a broken record, without a care for Palestinian lives.


The urgent question facing us in Gaza is not just how to survive for
today, but how to hold Israel accountable to international law and basic
principles of human rights; how to stop the current escalation and the
ongoing massacre and how to stop this from ever happening again.

Knowing that the credible Goldstone report on suspected war crimes in Gaza in 2008-09, and reports by Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch
are all ignored or undermined, there is a bitter awareness that we in
Gaza can have no expectation of Israeli accountability for the current
onslaught. But this is in the short term only — in the long term, we
know that Israel will have to answer to its oppression of Palestinians
because this oppression will end one day. History will have it no other

What Palestine needs from the world today is not just a condemnation
of the Gaza massacres and siege, but also a delegitimization of the
ideology that produced this policy and justifies it morally and
politically, just as the racist ideology of apartheid was delegitimized.

It seems, however, and again, as Ilan Pappe notices,
that even horrendous crimes, such as the genocide in Gaza, are treated
as “discrete events, unrelated to events in the past and dissociated
from any ideology or system.” Supporters of Palestine must always relate
today’s massacres to the original sin of colonization of the land which
Israel has claimed for its own and the dispossession of its indigenous

The window of hope comes from the lessons we have learned from South
Africa, where the ugly apartheid regime came under mounting pressure
from outside. It is time for international civil society, as opposed to
the ineffectual United Nations, to redouble their support for our
struggle against apartheid in Palestine today. As Palestinians under
Israeli siege, occupation and apartheid, we increasingly rely on
international law and solidarity for our very survival. That solidarity
is needed more than ever today.

The best way to honor those killed, injured and made homeless in Gaza
is to raise your voices even louder and demand that governments impose sanctions against Israel. Now is the time to increase the number of universities and businesses that boycott Israel. Now is the time to demand divestment from more pension funds. Now is the time for more countries to cut all ties with Israel.

A country that fails to abide by international law, that refuses to
withdraw from Arab lands it has occupied since 1967, that practices
racism against its Palestinian citizens, that refuses to allow Palestinian refugees
to return to their homes and lands, is a country that should be
expelled from the community of nations. International solidarity with
Gaza and the Palestinians demands no less than the complete isolation of
apartheid Israel.

Haidar Eid is an independent political commentator from the Gaza Strip, Palestine.


Popular posts from this blog


TomDispatch: "Okay, it's another lemon, the second you've bought from the same used-car lot -- and for $1,000 more than the first. The transmission is a mess; the muffler's clunking; smoke's seeping out of the dashboard; and you've only had it a week. You took it, grudgingly, as a replacement for that beat-up old Camry that only lasted two months, but the salesman assured you it was a winner. No wonder you're driving onto the lot right now. Before you can even complain, the same salesman's there. He's firm. It's not his fault. You must have done something. Nonetheless, he's ready to offer you a great deal. For an extra 2,000 bucks, you can have the rusted-out Honda Prelude right behind him, the one that, as a matter of fact, has just burst into flames -- and, he assures you, it's a dandy. It may not look so great today, what with the smoking hood and all, but it's a vehicle for the ages.
Would you buy a used car from this man? (Hint…

US Military “Commemorates” Its Iraq Massacre. “Tell Them It’s the Sound of Freedom.”

US Military “Commemorates” Its Iraq Massacre. “Tell Them It’s the Sound of Freedom.”

April 23, 2014 "ICH"
“We gather tonight knowing that this generation of
heroes has made the United States safer and more
respected round the world.” 

(President Barack Obama, State of the Union address,
24th January 2012.)

As Easter was
celebrated in the US and UK with, for believers, the
message of hope, Fallujah, the region and much of
the country is again under siege, not this time by
US mass murderers, but by the US proxy government’s
militias armed with US delivered weapons. In 2003, a
month into the invasion, Easter Day fell on the same
day as this year, 20th April, as Iraqis of all
denominations and none, died were incarcerated,
tortured, found with their heads drilled, or no
heads, thrown on garbage piles. Easter Day
the following year, 2004 fell on Sund…