Skip to main content

Netanyahu’s ‘Telegenically Dead’ Comment Is Grotesque but Not Original

Netanyahu’s ‘Telegenically Dead’ Comment Is Grotesque but Not Original

Featured photo - Netanyahu’s ‘Telegenically Dead’ Comment Is Grotesque but Not Original

GAZA, PALESTINE - 2014/07/20:
Palestinian medics carry the
body of a child killed in
Shijaiyah east of Gaza City,
after Israel expanded its ground
offensive on the Gaza Strip
(Photo by Ibrahim Khader/Pacific
Press/LightRocket via Getty

want to pile up as many civilian dead as
they can. They use telegenically
dead Palestinians for their cause.

They want the more dead, the better.
Jews gradually are having to depend more and
more on themselves, and have recently found
a new trick. They knew the good-natured
German Michael in us, always ready to shed
sentimental tears for the injustice done to
them. One suddenly has the
impression that the Berlin Jewish population
consists only of little babies whose
childish helplessness might move us, or else
fragile old ladies. The Jews send out the
They may confuse some
harmless souls for a while, but not us. We
know exactly what the situation is.
than lard up the point with numerous defensive
caveats about what is and is not being said here
(which, in any event, never impede willful
media distorters
in their tactics), I’ll
simply note three brief points:
(1) To
compare aspects of A and B is not to posit that
A and B are identical (e.g., to observe that
Bermuda and Bosnia are both countries beginning
with the letter “B” is not to depict them as the
same, just as observing that both the U.S. in
2003 and Germany in 1938 launched aggressive

in direct violation of what were to become the
Nuremberg Principles
is not to equate the
two countries).
(2) In
general, the

universality of war rhetoric
 is a vital
fact, necessary to evaluate the merit of
contemporary claims used to justify militarism
(claims that a war amounts to mere “humanitarian
intervention”, for instance, have been

invoked over and over
to justify

even the most blatant aggression
Similarly, the notion that one is barred from
ever citing certain historical examples in order
to draw lessons for contemporary conflicts is

as dangerous as it is anti-intellectual
Anglo-American law has long recognized that
gross recklessness

is a form of intent
(“Fraudulent intent is
shown if a representation is made with reckless
indifference to its truth or falsity”). That’s
why reckless behavior even if unaccompanied by a
desire to kill people – e.g.,

randomly shooting a gun into a crowd of people
has long been viewed as sufficient to establish
criminal intent.
One can
say many things about a military operation that
results in

more than 75 percent of the dead being civilians
many of them children, aimed at a population
trapped in

a tiny area with no escape
. The claim that
there is no intent to kill civilians but rather
an intent to protect them is most assuredly not
among them. Even stalwart Israel supporter
Thomas Friedman

has previously acknowledged
that Israeli
assaults on Lebanon, and possibly in Gaza, are
intended ”to
inflict substantial property damage and
collateral casualties” because “the only
long-term source of deterrence was to exact
enough pain on the civilians”
to the extent it exists, is the classic
definition of “terrorism”). The
most generous claim one can make about what
Israel is now doing in Gaza is that it is driven
by complete recklessness toward

the civilian population it is massacring
, a
form of intent under centuries of well-settled
western law.
* * * * *
journalism is frequently criticized with great
justification, but there are a number of
American journalists in Gaza, along with
non-western ones, in order to tell the world
about what is happening there. That reporting is
incredibly brave and difficult, and

those who are doing it
highest respect
. Their work, along with the
prevalence of social media and internet
technology that allows
what is happening
, has changed the way
Israeli aggression is seen and understood this
time around.

Credit to

Jonathan Schwarz
, now working with Matt

forthcoming First Look Media digital publication
for finding the 1941 article cited here.


Popular posts from this blog

Nir Rosen: Gaza: Israel, Hamas and the logic of colonial power | Comment is free |

Nir Rosen: Gaza: Israel, Hamas and the logic of colonial power | Comment is free | "I have spent most of the Bush administration's tenure reporting from Iraq, Afghanistan, Lebanon, Somalia and other conflicts. I have been published by most major publications. I have been interviewed by most major networks and I have even testified before the senate foreign relations committee. The Bush administration began its tenure with Palestinians being massacred and it ends with Israel committing one of its largest massacres yet in a 60-year history of occupying Palestinian land. Bush's final visit to the country he chose to occupy ended with an educated secular Shiite Iraqi throwing his shoes at him, expressing the feelings of the entire Arab world save its dictators who have imprudently attached themselves to a hated American regime."

Call for the World Social Forum Free Palestine, Nov. 2012 in Brazil

Call for the World Social Forum Free Palestine, Nov. 2012 in Brazil
Occupied Palestine is part of every free heartbeat in this world and her cause continues to inspire solidarity across the globe.  The World Social Forum Free Palestine is an expression of the human instinct to unite for justice and freedom and an echo of the World Social Forum’s opposition to neo-liberal hegemony, colonialism, and racism through struggles for social, political and economic alternatives to promote justice, equality, and the sovereignty of peoples.

The WSF Free Palestine will be a global encounter of broad-based popular and civil society mobilizations from around the world. It aims to:

1. Show the strength of solidarity with the calls of the Palestinian people and the diversity of initiatives and actions aimed at promoting justice and peace in the region.

2. Create effective actions to ensure Palestinian self-determination, the creation of a Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital, and the fulfillme…